New Effective, Innovative Treatments for Neuropathic Pain
Chronic neuropathic pain is the result of actual nerve cell or axonal damage due to inflammation, trauma or degenerative disease. It is characterised by shooting/stabbing pain, as well as sensations of burning, tingling and numbness. Many different types of neuropathic pain share a common pathway of pathophysiology. Diabetic peripheral neuropathy, postherpetic neuralgia, complex regional pain syndrome type 1, fibromyalgia, postsurgical neuropathy, post-trauma neuropathy, visceral neuropathy, xenobiotic neuropathy and the idiopathic neuropathies all share the same pathway of sensory input and central modulation and inhibition.
Mechanism of Pain
Chronic neuropathic pain originates in either the periphery or central compartments, depending on the source of pain (Martin and Hagan, 1997). Noxious stimuli are detected in the periphery by nociceptors which stimulates afferent nerve fibres to process the pain signal to the CNS via the dorsal horn of the spinal chord. These afferent fibres are of two main types: The myelinated, fast A fibres and the unmyelinated, slow C fibres. The constant suffering of patients with neuropathic pain is mostly C-fibre input. Nociceptor sensory input from free nerve endings is also involved but uses afferent nerve fibres as a pathway of input to the CNS. Damage to tissue may directly excite nerve endings by mechanical, thermal, or chemical effects on the nerve membrane. Such damage also sets in process the sequence of events recognised as inflammation. Crucial to the mediation of pain and inflammation at the peripheral pain receptor is the conversion of arachidonic acid, via the enzyme cyclooxygenase, to prostaglandins. These act by lowering the threshold of excitability to other mediators released such as bradykinin, substance P, thromboxanes, leukotrienes, nerve growth factor and histamine. The action of NSAID’s is largely due to their ability to inhibit the action of cyclooxygenase. On the other hand, compounds such as capsaicin cause the release and then deplete stores of substance P leading to analgesia.
The gate control theory of pain explained the modulation of pain signals via a multiplicity of interneurones that synapse with the afferent fibres and descending inhibitory pathway in the dorsal horn (Baumann, 1997). Once the pain signal interfaces the dorsal horn synapse, it reaches the CNS via various pathways for interpretation of pain. The CNS recognition of pain stimulates the descending inhibitory signals with the net result of either resolution, modulation or gain of pain.
Activation of C-fibres induce the release of a number of chemical transmitters at the synapse. Substance P (slow acting) and glutamate (fast acting) are the most important. Glutamate released is able to then activate different types of receptors, most importantly the alpha-amino-3-hydroxy-5-methy-4-isoxazole propionic acid (AMPA) and N-methyl-D-aspartate (NMDA) receptors. The development of hyperalgesia and allodynia states is the result of the activation of NMDA receptors by glutamate (Gibb et al., 1994). Located throughout the brain, dorsal horn and periphery along C-fibres, the NMDA receptors play a crucial roll in the modulation of pain signals, the maintenance of chronic neuropathic pain and the development of hyperalgesia and allodynia (Liu, 1997; Sandkuhler et al., 1998; Yamamoto, 1996). NMDA receptor activation by glutamate in the dorsal horn results with the opening of the calcium channel, by magnesium displacement, allowing calcium to enter the intracellular space. Intracellular calcium stimulates a cascade of events releasing kinase C, arachidonic acid, substance P, endothelium-derived relaxing factor and other inflammatory mediators. These further facilitate the release of glutamate which activates more NMDA receptors causing a wind up effect. Substance P has been particularly implicated in enhancing this wind up and central sensitisation (Carlton et al., 1998B). This process leads to long-term potentiation of NMDA receptors (rather than opioid receptors) at the dorsal horn neurones resulting in hyperalgesia and allodynia (Bloom, 1996; Laughlin et al., 1997).
Evidence exists of sodium channel involvement in NMDA receptor modulation (Eide, 1998). Glutamate activation of the dorsal horn and/or peripheral AMPA receptors, which are located in close proximity to NMDA receptors, causes an intracellular influx of sodium. The result is a delayed calcium rise intracellularly and an increase in excitotoxicity. Intracellular sodium indirectly induces the reduction of the GABA and opioid inhibitory systems increasing excitotoxicity which is a precursor to long-term potentiation. Glutamate antagonists may preventing AMPA receptor activation thus reducing the sensation of pain.
Peripheral insult that stimulates action at the NMDA/AMPA receptors also involve other systems: substance P, agonists and antagonists, GABA agonists and the free radical system.
Opioid receptor agonists block substance P release and dull the sensation of pain. The opioids do not ameliorate neuropathic pain very effectively when used as monotherapy and also tend to develop tolerance and an array of side effects.
There is evidence to suggest that there is an adrenergic component of cutaneous hyperalgesia in painful peripheral neuropathy. Clinical observations suggest that cutaneous sensitivity to noradrenaline contributes to chronic neuropathic pain. There is extensive, but antidotal, literature reporting the relief of the acute pain of herpes zoster in thousands of patients by local alpha 1 sympathetic blockage (Choi, 1997).The epidermal concentration of alpha 1 adrenergic receptors in hyperalgesic skin when compared to normal skin was found to be significantly greater in patients with neuropathic pain (Drummond et al., 1996).
The alpha 2 adrenergic receptors are located in the periphery and CNS. Topical alpha 2 agonists have also proved to be effective in treating hyperalgesia. Alpha 2 Agonist act by activating prejunctional receptors inhibiting the release of norepinephrine from sympathetic terminals.
GABA agonist action is inhibitory to pain signals. Specifically, the GABAb receptor is a member of the metabotropic (G protein-coupled) complex associated with the NMDA receptor modulation of sensory input (Bloom, 1996). Agents that are GABAb agonists (baclofen) are useful concomitantly with NMDA antagonists to mitigate glutaminergic calcium influx more effectively than either alone.
The involvement of free radicals in excitotoxicity provides evidence for their use in the treatment of neuropathic pain (Schultz et al., 1995).
This brief summary is certainly not inclusive as much yet needs to be learned regarding the pathophysiology of neuropathic pain. It is, however, a more complete basis of understanding than ever before.
Current Pain Management
The treatment of central and peripheral neurogenic pain is difficult. Patients are refractory to nonopioid analgesics, including NSAID’s, and rarely respond to opioids except at very high doses. This usually causes an array of side effects and leads to the rapid development of tolerance. Medication which helps dampen the activity of spontaneously hyperactive nociceptive neurones may help. These include amitriptyline and other tricyclic antidepressants, and anticonvulsants such as carbamazepine. Oral doses are usually titrated in accordance with the clinical response and side effects, which again are numerous.
New Pain Management Treatment
Considering the barriers to effective pain management it is time to consider a different approach to the problem as we enter a new millennium. Therapeutic manipulation has been experimentally achieved by using substances that:
- (a) block the excitatory process, such as NSAID’s and local anaesthetics, or
- (b) enhance the inhibitory response in the cord, such as opioids, alpha 2 agonists, GABA agonists, or
- (c) block the NMDA receptor, eg Ketamine or Dextrometorphan.
Therapeutic application of many of these substances is at a promising, but still experimental phase.
(1) Ketamine - a very effective noncompetitive NMDA antagonist, has been used orally for over 30 years to produce dissociative anaesthesia and more recently to successfully treat chronic neuropathic pain (Hoffmann, 1994). Potential problems with oral dosing is sensory and perceptional illusions, disorientation and vivid dreams at higher doses. Topical ketamine has been used to effectively treat sympathetically maintained pain without any reported side effects (Crowley et al., 1998). Topical application is recommended for localised pain where as low dose oral administration is recommended in cases where pain exists over a large area. Ketamine is now being used by pain specialists in pain clinics throughout Australia with great success where other treatments have failed.
(2) The glutamate antagonist, gabapentin, has also been used orally to treat chronic neuropathic pain (Backonja et al., 1998; Rowbotham et al., 1998). The high oral doses required often cause unwanted side effects which reduces patient compliance. Glutamate receptors have been found to reside at the dermal-epidermal junction so it was hypothesised that topical application could be a form of therapy for pain states either induced or maintained by peripheral primary afferent activity (Davidson et al., 1997). Anecdotal reports confirm that topical application is effective without any side effects.
(3) Topical application of the alpha 2 agonist, clonidine, has also decreased or abolished hyperalgesia in patients with features of reflex sympathetic dystrophy (Davies et al., 1991).
A new approach is now emerging that is able to effectively reduce suffering and side effects by using Low Dose, Combination, Transdermal Pain Therapy (LCTPT). The knowledge of receptor location now provides a different route of administration to avoid oral or systemic doses and their associated side effects. Alpha 1 Receptors and glutamate receptors have been reported to be located in the periphery (Drummond et al., 1996), opioid and alpha 2 receptors are known to exist locally, evidence of NMDA receptors in the epidermal-dermal junction have been reported (Carlton, 1998A; Davidson et al., 1997) and the AMPA receptors are located in close proximity to NMDA receptors. Based on the evidence presented effective pain relief may be achieved using low dose topical administration thus avoiding side effects associated with oral medications.
The theory of LCTPT starts with three medications with complementary modes of action being incorporated into a penetration enhanced topical base. Based on the key roll that the NMDA receptor performs in causing pain and suffering, an NMDA antagonist should be the first primary ingredient. A glutamate/AMPA antagonist second and either an alpha 1-antagonist, alpha 2-agonist, norepinephrine reuptake inhibitor or GABAb agonist, third. If inflammation is implicated a NSAID should also be included. One gram of this starting formula is applied directly to the localised area of pain and to the corresponding dorsal horn area of the involved dermatome. It is applied at eight hour intervals on a regular basis and every two hours in-between, as needed, for breakthrough pain. Dose escalation can occur daily or every other day until pain is relieved or, rarely, if side effects occur. Additional items from the third list should be added (with a different mode of action) after one to two weeks, if required. Again, dose escalation and evaluation should be repeated, if required.
Using the guidelines described above a medication is chosen from each category at the appropriate strength and incorporated into the formula. Ingredients are chosen based on the requirements of each individual thus customising their medication. Ongoing changes to the formula may be necessary until the most effective formula is found. This may involve dosage adjustments or changes to the combinations of the types of medications used.
Several starting formulas have been suggested and may be used as a guide. Their effectiveness has been well established by compounding pharmacies throughout the world (Jones, 2000; Angelle, 2000; Oberlander, 2000; Wood, 2000) Unfortunately, most of the evidence is antidotal as expensive clinical trials have not yet been performed. Pharmaceutical companies are not willing to invest vast amounts of money into this research because they do not stand to profit from it as these treatments are not patentable. It has therefore been left up to pioneering doctors and compounding pharmacists to establish effective and safe dosage protocols. The formulas listed below have been used on thousands of patients world wide and have proven themselves to be very effective in relieving neuropathic pain without any side effects.
- An effective starting formula for any type of neuropathic pain, especially diabetic neuropathy, may be 10% Ketamine, 6% Gabapentin and 0.2% clonidine. If after one week pain relief is not satisfactory add 2% baclofen and/or 2% amitriptyline. Again, after another week if it is still not successful add 5% loperamide. In addition, 100 to 300mg of alpha lipoic acid should be taken orally three times a day for diabetic neuropathy as numerous studies reveal it is able to reduce associated pain.
- An effective formula for Herpes Zoster (shingles) contains 5% Acyclovir, 10% lidocaine, 10% Ketoprofen, and 2% amitriptyline. Postherpetic neuralgia is best treated with the first formula listed above.
- An effective starting formula for more inflammatory pain is 15% ketoprofen, 7% amitriptyline and 5% lignocaine.
- An effective formula for diabetics with sensory peripheral neuropathy includes 8% Nifedipine and 5% ketamine, in an attempt to prevent the development of diabetic neuropathy from neuronal apoptosis numbness and the resultant high risk of amputation.
- Another effective starting formula for all types of neuropathic pain is 10% lidocaine, 7% amitriptyline and 7% carbamazepine.
- An effective formula for severe arthritic pain is 0.075% capsaicin, 2% Ketamine and 10% Ketoprofen.
- For patients who are unable to apply a cream to the skin due to severe pain may require to pretreat the area with a 5% Ketoprofen and 10% aspirin in ether spray. It is sprayed on the area and allowed to dry for 5 to 10 minutes prior to applying the cream.
- For patients whom experience pain over a large area low doses of oral ketamine is very effective. Doses between 25 to 100mg three times a day is effective in treating pain with minimal side effects. It is recommended to start low and gradually increase the dose until the desired effect is achieved.
The most important thing to note is that it is possible and preferential to customise a formula to best suite the needs of each individual patient. Changes in medications and their strength may be necessary in order to find the most effective formula. This process will require patience on behalf of the patient and the prescribing doctor, but once the correct formula is found very effective and safe pain management is assured. I encourage patients to contact myself whenever they feel that they require assistance and I closely monitor their progress keeping you, their doctor, up to date. I must emphasise the importance that open communication is maintained between the triad of patient, doctor and pharmacist to ensure a beneficial outcome for the patient.
Preventing Opioid Tollerance
While on the subject of pain management new research indicates that dextromethorphan is capable of attenuating and/or reversing opioid tolerance which is responsible for escalating opioid doses with chronic use (Elliott et al, 1994). The mechanism for this is believed to involve both NMDA receptor-gated and non-NMDA receptor-gated calcium and sodium channels. Dextromethorphan is a noncompetitive NMDA receptor antagonist. Opioid tolerance requires a functional NMDA receptor, and blockage of this receptor prevents developement of opioid tolerance. It also attenuates intracellular Ca influx through NMDA receptor-gated channels as well as voltage-gated Ca channels. It also blocks current through voltage-gated Ca and Na channels (Kane and Glasnapp, 1998). Our laboratory compounds dextromethorphan capsules which may be used in conjunction with opioid therapy to prevent opioid dose escalation.
If you have any queries or requests feel free to contact us as we will do all we can to assist.
Kind Regards
Dr Michael Serafin B.Pharm (Hon) Ph.D. MIACP
Pharmaceutical Chemist/Pharmacist.
References - Most of the original articles are available on request.
- Alley, K.O., Levine, J.D., Multiple receptors involved in peripheral 2, , and A1 antinociception, tolerance, and withdrawal. Soc Neurosci., 17, 735 - 744 (1977).
- Angelle, P., Postherpetic neuralgia. Int J Pharm Comp., 4, 27 - 29 (2000).
Backonja, M., Baydoun, A., Edwards, K.R., et al. Gabapentin for the symptomatic treatment of painful neuropathy in patients with diabetes mellitus: A randomised controlled study. JAMA, 280, 1831 - 1836 (1998).
- Baumann, T. Pain management. Pharmacotherapy: A Pathophysiological Approach. 1259 - 1278 (1997).
- Bloom, F.E. Neurotransmission and the nervous system. Goodman and Gilman�s The pharmacological Basis of Therapeutics, ed 9. 276 - 294 (1996).
- Carlton, S.M., Zhou, S. Attenuation of formalin induced nociceptive behaviours following local peripheral injection of gabapentin. Pain, 76, 210 - 217 (1998A).
- Carlton, S.M., Zhou, S., Coggeshall, R.E., Evidence for the interaction of glutamate and substance P receptors in the periphery, Brain Res., 790, 160 - 169 (1998B).
- Choi, B., Rowbotham, M.C., Effect of adrenergic receptor activation on post-herpatic neuralgia pain and sensory disturbance. Pain, 69, 55 - 63 (1997).
- Crowley, K., Flores, J., Hughes, C., Iacono, R.P., Clinical application of ketamine ointment in the treatment of sympathetically maintained pain. Int J Pharm Comp., 2, 122 - 125 (1998).
- Davies, K.D., Treede, R.D., Raja, S.N., Meter, R.A. Topical application of clonidine relieves hyperalgesia in patients with sympathetically maintained pain. Pain, 47, 309 - 317 (1991).
Davidson, E.M., Coggeshall, R.E., Carlton, S.M. Peripheral NMDA and non-NMDA glutamate receptors contribute to nociceptive behaviours in rat formalin test. Neurorepsrt. 8, 941 - 946 (1997).
- Drummond, P.D., Skipworth, S., Finch, P.M. Alpha-1-adrenoreceptors in normal and hyperalgesic human skin. Clin Sci., 91, 73 - 77 (1996).
- Elliott, K., Hynansky, A., Inturrisi, C.E., Dextromethorphan attenuates and reverses analgesic tolerance to morphine. Pain, 59, 361 - 368 (1994).
- Eide, P.K. Pathophysiological mechanisms of ventral neuropathic pain after spinal cord injury. Spinal Cord 36, 601 - 612 (1998).
- Gibb, A.J., Edmonds, B and Silver, R.A. Activation of NMDA receptors. The NMDA receptor, ed 2, Oxford university Press, 219 - 242 (1994).
- Hoffmann, V., Coppejans, H., Verauteren, M. Successful treatment of postherpetic neuralgia with oral ketamine. Clin J Pain, 10, 240 - 242 (1994).
- Jones, M., Chronic neuropathic pain: Pharmacological interventions. Int J Pharm Comp, 4, 6 - 15 (2000).
- Kane, D.L. and Glasnapp, A., Dextromethorphan and opioid tolerance. Int J Comp Pharm., 2, 118 - 119 (1998).
- Laughlin, T.M., Vanderah, T.W., Lashbrook, J et al. Spinal administered dynorphin A produces long-lasting allodynia. Involvement of NMDA but not opioid receptors. Pain, 72, 253 - 260 (1997).
- Liu, X and Sandkuhler, J. Characterisation of long-term potentiation of C-fibre-evoked potential’s in spinal dorsal horn of adult rat. J Neurophysiol., 78, 1973 - 1982 (1997).
Martin, L.A and Hagen, NA, Neuropathic pain in cancer patients: Mechanisms, syndromes, and clinical controversies. J Pain Symptom Manage, 14, 99 -117 (1997).
- Oberlander, K., Fibromyalgia. Int J Pharm Comp., 4, 21 - 23 (2000).
- Rowbotham, M., Hardin, N., Stacey, B., et al., Gabapentin for the treatment of postherpetic neuralgia: A randomised controlled study. JAMA, 280, 1837 - 1842 (1998).
Sandkuhler J., Liu, X. Induction of log term potentiation at spinal synapses by noxious stimulation or nerve injury. Eur J Neurosci, 10, 2476 - 2480 (1998).
- Schultz, J.B., Henshaw, D.R., Siwek, D., Involvement of free radicals in excitotoxicity in vivo. J Neurochem., 64, 2239 - 2247 (1995).
- Wood, R.M., Ketamine for pain in hospice patients. Int J Pharm Comp., 4, 253 - 254 (2000).
- Yamamoto, T. NMDA receptor and pain. Masui, 45, 1312 - 1318 (1996).
Copyright 2001 Michael Serafin, Ph.D.